The EdUp Experience
HomePodcastEditorialsPartnersCoverageReviews
EdUp Leadership
EdUp Editorials

Commentary

Three Questions College Leaders Should Ask Before Comparing Graduation Rates

All graduation rates are not created equal.

KS

Kayva Sree Mariboyina

Director of Institutional Effectiveness, Little Priest Tribal College

Nov 19, 2026 3 min read
Three Questions College Leaders Should Ask Before Comparing Graduation Rates

By Kavya Sree Mariboyina, Director of Institutional Effectiveness, Little Priest Tribal College

Imagine two colleges put a 30 percent graduation rate on the screen at a board meeting. At one college, the rate follows first-time, full-time students. At the other, it follows a broader group that includes part-time students and students who transferred in. Both numbers can be accurate. Comparing them at face value can still lead the board to the wrong conclusion about how well each college serves its students.

As Director of Institutional Effectiveness at Little Priest Tribal College, I spend a lot of time thinking about what happens between calculating a number and putting it in front of the people who will use it. We often devote considerable attention to getting the calculation right. The next step deserves just as much attention. What will someone reasonably conclude when they see this number on a slide?

Before comparing graduation rates across colleges or using a rate to set a campus goal, I would ask three questions.

1. Who is included in the rate?

Start with the denominator. Which students entered the cohort, what counted as completion, and how much time did students have to finish? If the answers differ across two rates, that difference belongs in the conversation before anyone draws a conclusion about performance. This matters within a college, too. A board may see one graduation rate in an external report and another on an institutional dashboard. If the numbers differ, people may reasonably ask which one is correct. The answer might be that the two measures follow different groups of students or use different time frames.

A short note directly beneath the chart can make that distinction clear. For example, a chart could say, “Tracks first-time, full-time degree-seeking students who completed a credential at this college within three years.” That gives readers enough information to understand the number before they compare it with another one.

2. Whose progress does the rate leave out?

At a two-year college, the students in a traditional graduation cohort represent only part of the campus. Depending on the measure, students who begin part time, transfer in, or take courses while still in high school may fall outside the group being tracked. Their pathways raise different questions. For example, if we want to understand whether our dual enrollment program helps local high school students transition to college, we could look at how many subsequently enroll in a credential program after high school. If we want to understand how part-time degree seekers are progressing, we might look at whether they continue enrolling and accumulate credits toward their programs. Each question calls for a clearly defined group and a measure that fits the decision.

At Little Priest Tribal College, we have complemented traditional graduation measures with institutional indicators that capture the completion pathways of part-time students. By tracking the number of graduates and median attended semesters for full-time and part-time students, we gain a clearer understanding of student success beyond conventional cohort-based measures. These additional indicators help us recognize progress that traditional graduation rates may not fully capture. Colleges can keep reporting their established graduation rates and add focused measures where they need a clearer picture. The starting point is deciding whose progress the institution wants to understand.

3. What decision are we trying to make?

Suppose a leadership team has funding for additional advising and wants to use it to improve completion. A graduation rate can help the team see whether completion outcomes have changed. To decide how to use the funding, the team needs to know where students are encountering barriers. If many students are leaving after their first term, the college could examine what happened during that term and talk with students about what made it difficult to return. If students are reaching their final year but struggling to finish, the team could look at which requirements remain and whether the courses students need are available when they can take them. Those situations call for different conversations with students, advisors, and faculty.

I would start a dashboard discussion by asking everyone in the room to name the decision in front of them. Then I’d put the cohort definition beside the rate and ask what other information would help us make that decision. Sometimes the next step is another data point. Sometimes it’s a conversation with the students whose experience we’re trying to understand.

EdUp Editorials

This is where our team writes down what the conversations reveal. New editorials are published weekly.

More editorials

More Commentary from EdUp

Commentary

The Wall Between Admissions and Career Services Is Holding Students Back

By Bobby Gandu

Bobby Gandu · Sep 3, 2026 · 5 min read

Commentary

Teaching the Humans Who Teach the Humans

By: Dr. Freda Barnett-Braddock

Dr. Freda Barnett-Braddock · Aug 19, 2026 · 4 min read

Commentary

Confronting the School Mental Health Crisis

Innovative Models Support Students and Teachers

Karen G. Foley · Jul 13, 2026 · 2 min read

The EdUp Weekly Newsletter · free weekly email

One email. Every conversation that matters in higher ed.

New episodes, upcoming guests, and a handful of issues colleagues across the landscape are discussing. Multi-media learning for higher education professionals.

Free, weekly, and easy to leave. We never sell your details.

  • Published every week, and only when there is something worth saying.
  • Unsubscribe in one click, no questions asked.
The EdUp Experience

Higher Education Media Company

It’s YOUR time to #EdUp.

We make education YOUR business!

1,502

Episodes

1,535

Guests

2020

Broadcasting since

Explore

  • Podcast & Guests
  • EdUp Editorials
  • Media Coverage
  • Podcast Network

Company

  • About EdUp
  • HigherEd PodCon
  • EdUp Press
  • Partner with EdUp
  • Become a Guest
  • Contact the Team

Listen & follow

  • Apple Podcasts
  • Spotify

The EdUp Weekly Newsletter

One email a week: new episodes, guest announcements and the higher-ed conversations worth your time.

Free, weekly, and easy to leave. We never sell your details.

© 2026 The EdUp Experience. All rights reserved.

edupexperience@gmail.comPrivacy & terms

    The EdUp Weekly Newsletter

    One email. Every conversation that matters in higher ed.

    Join the higher-ed leaders who get the new episodes, guest announcements and reporting in their inbox each week.

    Free, weekly, and easy to leave. We never sell your details.